Contact
Wilmington Corporate Office
209 Main St, Wilmington, DE 19804
Direct Line: 1-302-463-8294
Roofing Materials
By Becker’s Chimney and RoofingReviewed by Brandon Becker, OwnerUpdated Serving Delaware, Southeastern PA, South Jersey & Maryland
Quick Answer
A metal roof lasts longer. Standing seam metal typically delivers 40 to 70 years of service, compared with 20 to 30 years for architectural asphalt shingles. Metal also costs about 63 percent more up front, based on national 2025 Cost vs. Value averages. It usually wins on cost per year only if you will own the home for decades. If you expect to sell within 10 to 15 years, architectural shingles generally return more of their cost.
Homeowners usually ask this question the moment they see two quotes side by side. The metal number is much higher, and the salesperson’s answer is that it lasts much longer. Both statements are true. What matters is whether the extra years actually benefit you, which depends on how long you plan to stay, where the house sits, and what the roof has to handle.
We install both materials, so we have no reason to push one. This guide lays out how long each roof really lasts, what shortens that life in our climate, what each one costs per year of service, how warranties and resale value compare, and which situations favor which material.
01
Architectural shingles typically last 20 to 30 years, and a quality metal roof typically lasts 40 to 70. Basic 3-tab shingles fall short of both at roughly 15 to 20 years. Those ranges line up with the life expectancy chart published by InterNACHI, the home inspector association, which lists 30 years for architectural shingles and 40 to 80 years for metal.
Typical Service Life by Roofing Material
Ranges are typical service life with proper installation and routine maintenance. Where a roof falls within its range depends on ventilation, sun exposure, roof pitch, storm history, and installation quality. For metal, the panel system and finish matter as much as the metal itself.
The ranges are wide for a reason. A shingle roof over a well-ventilated attic on a shaded north slope can outlast the same shingle over a hot, poorly vented attic by many years. Metal varies even more, because “metal roof” covers everything from screw-down panels to standing seam systems with concealed clips.
Standing seam is the type that earns the long end of the range. Its fasteners sit hidden under the raised seams, and the panels attach with clips that let the metal expand and contract with temperature. Exposed-fastener panels cost less but rely on thousands of screws with rubber washers, and those washers are the part that ages first. A well-detailed exposed-fastener roof can still serve for decades, but it needs periodic fastener checks that standing seam does not.
02
Heat and moisture shorten shingle life, while corrosion and installation details shorten metal life. In both cases, the materials rarely fail on their own. Something around them speeds up the aging.
Attic heat is the biggest factor. Shingles over a hot, poorly ventilated attic lose their oils faster, then curl, crack, and shed granules. Our humid summers also feed the dark algae streaks common on north-facing slopes in this region, which is why algae-resistant granules are worth asking about. Proper roof ventilation and a sound deck underneath do more to extend shingle life than any upgrade to the shingle itself.
Metal usually fails at its edges, penetrations, and fasteners rather than across the open panels. Poorly detailed flashing at chimneys and walls, cut edges left unprotected, and the wrong metal for the location cause most early problems. Finish quality matters too. Premium paint systems hold their color and resist chalking for decades, while lower-grade finishes fade sooner even if the metal underneath stays sound.
Not Sure Which Roof Fits Your Plans?
We install both architectural shingles and metal roofing, so our recommendation is not tied to selling one material. Ask us to price both options on the same visit and see the real difference for your home.
03
A standing seam metal roof can cost less per year of service, but only if it lasts long enough to make up for its higher price. Based on national averages, metal has to last about 41 years to beat a 25-year shingle roof on a per-year basis.
The most consistent comparison comes from the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report published by Zonda and the JLC Group, which prices both projects on the same 3,000 square foot hip roof. The national average was $31,871 for an asphalt shingle replacement and $51,865 for standing seam metal. In the Middle Atlantic region, which includes Pennsylvania and New Jersey, both ran higher at $37,201 and $60,116, but metal still cost about 62 percent more. Dividing each national cost by its typical service life gives a clearer picture than the sticker price alone.
Estimated Cost Per Year of Roof Service
Calculated from 2025 Cost vs. Value national averages ($31,871 for asphalt shingles, $51,865 for standing seam metal) divided by service lives of 20 to 30 years for architectural shingles and 40 to 70 years for metal. This does not account for inflation, financing, maintenance, or energy costs. Your own quote will differ with roof size, pitch, and complexity.
The overlap is the honest part of this chart. A metal roof that lasts 40 years lands right alongside a shingle roof that lasts 25. The per-year advantage only becomes clear when metal reaches 50 years or more, and only the person who still owns the house at that point collects it.
Resale works against metal in the short run. Nationally, the metal roof added about $4,500 more resale value than the shingle roof while costing about $20,000 more. Buyers value a new roof, but they pay little extra for decades of additional life. For a homeowner planning to move within 10 to 15 years, that difference usually outweighs metal’s longer life. Our guide on how much it costs to replace a roof covers what drives the price on either material.
04
A “lifetime” shingle warranty does not mean the roof lasts a lifetime, and a metal warranty usually covers the paint and the metal separately. Reading what each warranty actually covers tells you more than the headline number.
GAF, North America’s largest roofing manufacturer, defines “Lifetime” as the period the original owner owns a single-family detached home. The full, non-prorated coverage on its standard warranty runs for the first 10 years, and coverage is reduced after that. Upgraded system warranties extend the non-prorated period on materials to 50 years. The top tier, GAF’s Golden Pledge, adds the longest workmanship coverage, requires qualifying GAF accessory products, and can only be offered by GAF Master Elite contractors.
Metal roofing warranties are usually split in two. A substrate warranty covers the metal against corrosion, and a separate paint warranty covers the finish. A premium finish might carry 40 years against peeling and cracking, but only 30 years against chalking and fading. Coastal installations often get shorter terms, and some coastal warranties require the owner to rinse the roof with fresh water on a schedule and keep records.
| Warranty Term | Architectural Shingles | Metal Roofing |
|---|---|---|
| Headline length | Often “Lifetime,” defined by ownership of the home | Often 30 to 40 years on the paint finish |
| Full coverage period | 10 years non-prorated on a standard GAF warranty, up to 50 years on upgraded systems | Varies by manufacturer, with paint and metal covered separately |
| Installation errors | Covered only by upgraded manufacturer warranties or the contractor’s own warranty | Typically the contractor’s workmanship warranty, so ask what it covers and for how long |
05
Both materials handle our weather well when installed correctly, but they respond differently. Metal sheds snow and does not absorb water, while shingles hold snow longer and depend more on attic conditions. Near the coast, the specific metal chosen becomes the deciding factor.
| Condition | Architectural Shingles | Metal Roofing |
|---|---|---|
| High wind | GAF’s 15-year wind warranty has no maximum wind speed for its LayerLock shingles when installed with the required accessories | Ratings depend on the panel, clip spacing, and deck attachment, so ask for the tested assembly |
| Hail | Available in UL 2218 Class 4 impact-rated versions. Hail can bruise shingles and knock off granules | Also available in Class 4 versions. Hail can leave dents that are permanent but often cosmetic |
| Snow and ice | Holds snow, so ice protection at the eaves and a well-sealed attic matter | Sheds snow quickly, so snow guards are needed above doors, walkways, and lower roofs |
| Humidity | Prone to algae streaking without algae-resistant granules | Does not absorb moisture. How it weathers depends on the finish |
| Salt air | The shingles are not affected, though flashing metals still matter | The choice of metal is critical, and painted aluminum is generally preferred near saltwater |
Hail deserves a note for insurance purposes. A dented metal roof may remain completely watertight, and some policies treat purely cosmetic damage to metal roofing differently than functional damage. If you live in an area that sees hail, ask your insurer how your policy handles it before you choose. Our roof hail damage repair team works with both materials.
Salt air matters for homes along the Delaware beaches, the Delaware Bay, and the tidal rivers. Steelscape, a major steel coil producer, recommends having any metal roof within a mile of saltwater reviewed by the panel manufacturer, and it names painted aluminum as the best choice in those locations. Architectural shingles avoid the corrosion question entirely, which is one reason they remain common in coastal neighborhoods.
They attract lightning. They do not. According to the Metal Construction Association, roofing material does not make a strike more likely, because a building’s height and surroundings decide where lightning lands. Metal is also noncombustible if a strike does occur.
They are loud in the rain. Over solid sheathing, underlayment, and an insulated attic, which is how residential metal roofs are installed, rain noise is far less noticeable than most people expect. The loud metal roofs people remember are usually on barns and sheds with no deck underneath.
06
Let your ownership timeline decide first, then adjust for location and roof shape. Most homeowners who plan to stay 25 years or more get the most from metal. Most who expect to sell within 15 years get more value from architectural shingles.
| Your Situation | Usually the Better Fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Selling within 10 to 15 years | Architectural shingles | Lower up-front cost and a higher share recouped at resale |
| Staying 25 years or longer | Standing seam metal | Lowest cost per year when it reaches its full service life |
| Within a mile of saltwater | Either, chosen carefully | Shingles avoid corrosion concerns, and metal should be painted aluminum or a manufacturer-approved coastal system |
| Low-slope roof sections | Standing seam metal | Building codes do not allow shingles below a 2:12 pitch and require extra underlayment below 4:12, while many standing seam systems are rated for lower slopes |
| Planning solar panels | Standing seam metal | Panels can clamp to the seams instead of requiring holes through the roof |
| Tight budget right now | Architectural shingles | Far lower initial cost, with financing available for either option |
| HOA or historic district rules | Check the rules first | Some communities restrict metal roofing or specific colors. See our HOA roofing page |
Whichever you choose, the condition of the deck underneath matters as much as the roofing on top. A full tear-off during a roof replacement lets the sheathing be checked for signs of damaged decking and repaired before new material goes down, so it is worth asking about with any quote. Both our architectural shingle and metal roofing pages show the options we install.
Becker’s Chimney and Roofing is a family-owned company founded in 2013 by Brandon and Stefani Becker. We install architectural shingles and metal roofing across Delaware, southeastern Pennsylvania, South Jersey, and Maryland, which lets us recommend the material that fits your plans instead of the one we happen to sell.
“Becker’s Chimney & Roofing did an excellent job replacing my roof and re-pitching my gutters. … Great workmanship and a smooth experience from start to finish.”
Colin S., Google review
Compare Both Roofs for Your Home
We will inspect your roof, price architectural shingles and metal side by side, and explain which fits how long you plan to stay. You get a written estimate before any work begins.
Roughly, yes. Standing seam metal typically lasts 40 to 70 years, while architectural shingles typically last 20 to 30. A well-installed metal roof often outlives two shingle roofs. Exposed-fastener metal panels can fall short of that because their screws and washers need periodic attention.
It depends mostly on how long you will own the home. Standing seam metal cost about 63 percent more than an asphalt shingle roof in the 2025 national Cost vs. Value averages. It pays off per year of service only if it lasts roughly 41 years or more, so it suits long-term owners better than people planning to sell soon.
No. For GAF shingles, “Lifetime” means for as long as the original owner owns a single-family detached home. The standard warranty is non-prorated for the first 10 years and reduces coverage after that, while upgraded system warranties extend non-prorated material coverage to 50 years.
No. The Metal Construction Association notes that roofing material does not affect where lightning strikes, since height and surroundings decide that. If a metal roof is struck, the metal itself is noncombustible and will not burn.
It can be, with the right material. Within about a mile of saltwater, industry guidance calls for the panel manufacturer to review the specific system, and painted aluminum is usually preferred over painted steel. Coastal metal warranties are often shorter and can require periodic freshwater rinsing.
An asphalt shingle replacement recouped 67.5 percent of its cost nationally in the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, compared with 50.1 percent for standing seam metal. Nationally, metal added only about $4,500 more in resale value than shingles while costing about $20,000 more.
Reviewed by Brandon Becker, Owner
Brandon Becker is the owner of Becker’s Chimney and Roofing, which he founded with Stefani Becker in 2013. He oversees the company’s shingle and metal roofing projects across Delaware, southeastern Pennsylvania, South Jersey, and Maryland. Last reviewed .
Wilmington Corporate Office
209 Main St, Wilmington, DE 19804
Direct Line: 1-302-463-8294
