Contact
Wilmington Corporate Office
209 Main St, Wilmington, DE 19804
Direct Line: 1-302-463-8294
Quick Answer
A wood stove is far more efficient. EPA-certified wood stoves turn roughly 60 to 85 percent of the wood’s energy into usable heat. A traditional open fireplace runs from about 10 percent down to below zero, which means it can pull more warm air out of the house than it puts back. If you already have a fireplace, a wood-burning insert brings it close to stove performance, at roughly 55 to 75 percent.
Few things feel warmer than a fire on a cold night, which is why so many homeowners are surprised to learn their fireplace may be making the house colder. The flames are hot, but most of that heat, along with a steady stream of already heated room air, goes straight up the chimney.
We sell and install wood stoves and fireplace inserts, and we build, reline, and repair the chimneys they vent through. This guide explains how big the efficiency gap really is, why it exists, what it takes to turn an existing fireplace into a real heat source, and how to choose the setup that fits the way you want to use it.
01
A certified wood stove delivers roughly six to eight and a half times more heat from the same wood than an open fireplace at its best. The University of Maryland Extension rates conventional fireplaces at minus 10 to 10 percent efficient and EPA-certified stoves at 60 to 85 percent. The U.S. Department of Energy’s figures line up, with new catalytic stoves reaching up to 83 percent and advanced non-catalytic stoves running 65 to 75 percent.
Heating Efficiency by Wood-Burning Appliance
Ranges from the University of Maryland Extension’s guide to buying a clean-burning wood stove. A negative figure means the fireplace pulls more heated room air up the chimney than the heat it puts back into the room. Actual results depend on the appliance, the chimney, how dry the wood is, and how the fire is run.
In practical terms, you burn far less wood for the same warmth, and the gap keeps widening the longer the fire runs. Even among stoves, age matters. The EPA notes that a certified stove uses about one third less wood than an older, uncertified stove to produce the same heat.
02
An open fireplace needs a huge volume of air to keep the fire burning and the smoke rising, and it takes that air from the room you are trying to heat. The Department of Energy notes that a traditional fireplace can draw as much as 300 cubic feet of heated room air per minute and send it straight up the chimney. Cold outdoor air then leaks in through windows, doors, and gaps to replace it.
The heat itself is lost the same way. Most of the fire’s energy rises with the exhaust, and the open firebox lets only a small share radiate into the room. That is why the spot directly in front of the fireplace feels warm while the rest of the house gets cooler. The DOE puts it plainly: traditional open masonry fireplaces should not be considered heating devices.
A wood stove solves both problems. Its sealed firebox controls the air supply, so it burns far less room air and burns the wood more completely. Its steel or cast iron body, and often a secondary combustion system, holds that heat and releases it into the room for hours instead of sending it up the flue.
Turn Your Fireplace Into Real Heat
We will inspect your chimney and firebox, tell you whether an insert or a freestanding stove fits your home, and handle the liner, chimney work, and installation in one project.
03
Yes. The most effective upgrade is a wood-burning fireplace insert, which is essentially a wood stove built to fit inside an existing masonry firebox. The Department of Energy notes that a well-fitted insert can function nearly as efficiently as a wood stove.
The chimney matters as much as the insert. Insert manufacturers specify the liner size and type in their installation instructions, and a full-length stainless steel liner running from the insert to the top of the chimney is the standard approach today. Older installations that only connected a short pipe partway up the chimney are the reason many inserts earned a reputation for smoke, weak draft, and hard cleaning. Our chimney liner installations are sized to the appliance, and our post on how to know if your chimney needs a new liner covers the warning signs.
Smaller upgrades help, but within limits. Tight-fitting glass doors and a top-sealing damper at the chimney cap cut the heated air that escapes when the fireplace is not in use. They do not turn an open fireplace into an efficient heater, though, because the fire still burns open to the room.
Many stove retailers still advertise a 30 percent federal tax credit, up to $2,000, for wood stoves rated at 75 percent efficiency or higher. That credit covered stoves purchased and installed through December 31, 2025, and it was not extended. A stove installed now does not qualify. State and local programs are separate and worth checking, but confirm current terms with a tax professional before counting on any incentive.
04
It depends on the stove’s heat output and the home’s layout and insulation. The Department of Energy offers a rule of thumb that a stove rated at 42,000 Btu can heat about 1,300 square feet. Open floor plans spread heat well, while closed rooms and long hallways keep it near the stove.
Bigger is not better. An oversized stove gets run at a low, smoldering fire to keep the room from overheating, and a smoldering fire burns dirty and builds creosote in the chimney faster. A stove sized to the space it heats burns hotter, cleaner, and with less wood. Our approach is to size the stove to your home and how you plan to use it, not to sell the largest model.
Firewood quality matters as much as the stove. Both the EPA and the DOE call for wood with a moisture content of 20 percent or less. The EPA recommends splitting wood to 6 inches or smaller and drying softwood for at least 6 months and hardwood for at least 12. Wet wood wastes much of its energy boiling off water and leaves more creosote behind.
05
A safe wood stove or insert needs a certified appliance, the right clearances, proper floor protection, a sound and correctly sized chimney, and regular inspection. Skipping any one of those is how most wood heating problems start.
| Requirement | What It Means |
|---|---|
| EPA-certified appliance | New wood heaters must meet EPA’s 2020 particulate limit of 2.0 grams per hour on crib wood or 2.5 on cord wood, which reflects cleaner, more complete burning |
| Listed clearances | The distance to walls, furniture, and trim is set by the stove’s safety listing label, and reduced clearances require approved heat shields |
| Floor protection | A noncombustible hearth pad extending beyond the stove and its loading door, as the listing specifies |
| Sound chimney | A flue in good condition and sized to the appliance, with a stainless liner for inserts and for masonry flues that are damaged or the wrong size |
| Annual inspection | NFPA 211 calls for inspecting chimneys and vents at least once a year |
| Carbon monoxide alarms | Working alarms outside sleeping areas and on every level of the home |
Wood stoves also change how often a chimney needs attention. A stove used as a primary heat source can reach the creosote level that requires cleaning within a single season. Our guide on how often a chimney should be cleaned or inspected breaks down the schedule by how much you burn, and we provide both chimney inspections and chimney cleaning.
06
Decide how you want to use the fire first. If it is mainly for atmosphere a few nights a year, an open fireplace in good repair is fine. If you want it to actually heat your home, you need a stove or an insert.
| Your Goal | Usually the Best Fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Occasional fires for atmosphere | Open fireplace with glass doors and a good damper | Keeps the open-flame experience and limits heat loss when not in use |
| Real heat from an existing fireplace | Wood-burning fireplace insert with a full-length liner | Uses the existing chimney and reaches near-stove efficiency |
| Primary or supplemental heat, no fireplace | Freestanding wood stove with a new chimney or listed chimney pipe | Highest efficiency and the most flexible placement |
| Backup heat during power outages | Freestanding wood stove | Radiates heat with no electricity, while many inserts rely on a blower for full output |
| Heating a large, open main floor | Properly sized freestanding stove | Radiant and convective heat spreads through open layouts |
Backup heat is a real consideration in our area, where winter storms and nor’easters can knock out power for days. A freestanding stove keeps at least part of the house warm with no electricity at all. For homes without an existing chimney, we can build one through our chimney installation service. If you have a fireplace that needs work before it can safely vent an insert, our chimney repair team handles that first.
Becker’s Chimney and Roofing started as a chimney company. Brandon and Stefani Becker founded it in 2013, and we still treat the stove, the liner, and the chimney as one system, because a wood stove is only as safe and efficient as what it vents through.
“Both of them were very responsive and very thorough in their work of both the chimney and gutter.”
Christine C., Google review
Get Real Heat From Your Fire This Winter
We will evaluate your fireplace or the space where a stove would go, check the chimney, and recommend the setup that fits, with a written estimate before any work begins.
Yes, by a wide margin. EPA-certified wood stoves run about 60 to 85 percent efficient, while traditional open fireplaces run from about 10 percent to below zero, according to the University of Maryland Extension. A certified stove delivers roughly six to eight and a half times more heat from the same wood.
It can. An open fireplace draws up to 300 cubic feet of heated room air per minute up the chimney, according to the Department of Energy, and cold outdoor air leaks in to replace it. The area in front of the fire feels warm while the rest of the home loses heat.
Close. EPA-certified wood-burning inserts run roughly 55 to 75 percent efficient, near the range of freestanding stoves. A freestanding stove usually radiates more heat into the room because more of its surface is exposed, and it keeps working during a power outage when an insert’s blower cannot.
In most cases, yes. Insert manufacturers specify the liner in their installation instructions, and a full-length stainless steel liner sized to the insert is the standard approach. It provides reliable draft, makes the chimney easier to clean, and protects the masonry from heat and corrosive flue gases.
Not at the federal level for new installations. The 30 percent biomass stove credit, worth up to $2,000 for stoves rated at 75 percent efficiency or higher, covered stoves purchased and installed through December 31, 2025. State and local programs may still exist, so confirm with a tax professional.
Match the stove’s output to the area you want to heat. The Department of Energy’s rule of thumb is that a 42,000 Btu stove heats about 1,300 square feet. An oversized stove run at low fires burns dirty and builds creosote faster, so the right size matters for safety as well as efficiency.
Reviewed by Brandon Becker, Owner
Brandon Becker is the owner of Becker’s Chimney and Roofing, which he founded with Stefani Becker in 2013. He oversees the company’s chimney, wood stove, and roofing projects across Delaware, southeastern Pennsylvania, South Jersey, and Maryland. Last reviewed .